Backstreet Boys star Howie Dorough has married his girlfriend Leigh Boniello in a fairytale wedding on Saturday.

The 34-year-old singer and real estate broker Boniello exchanged vows in Dorough’s native Orlando, Fla., in a Catholic ceremony at St. James Cathedral, reports People.com.

One guest says, “The whole thing was like it belonged in a bridal magazine. It was absolutely perfect.”

The couple has been dating since 2000 and Dorough proposed to the former film executive in January.